"Lights failed and a crash followed? The council can be liable — but only if you act fast on evidence."
100% free · No obligation · No win, no fee
When traffic lights fail, malfunction, or show contradictory signals, drivers can be put in genuinely impossible positions. The local highway authority owes a duty to maintain signalling equipment, and faulty lights resulting in a collision can ground a claim.
Scotland operates under Scots law (separate from English law) and does NOT apply the 2021 whiplash tariff. Every claim is individually assessed by a Scottish solicitor and processed through the Sheriff Court system, meaning compensation is typically 2–5x higher than for an identical injury in England.
Liability is the central question in any Scottish claim. Here are the most common scenarios for faulty traffic lights accident cases:
Liable for failure to maintain signal equipment within reasonable timescales.
Where one party had green and another had failed lights, fault is heavily contested — junction CCTV is decisive.
Scottish claims are individually assessed — there is NO whiplash tariff cap. These ranges reflect actual settlements and Sheriff Court awards.
| Injury type | Compensation range |
|---|---|
| Minor whiplash (under 3 months) | £1,000 – £3,000 |
| Moderate whiplash (6–12 months) | £5,000 – £10,000 |
| Significant neck/back injury (12–18 months) | £8,000 – £18,000 |
| Severe back / disc damage | £15,000 – £45,000 |
| Concussion / mild brain injury | £3,000 – £15,000 |
| Moderate brain injury | £45,000 – £150,000 |
| Broken bones (wrist/arm/leg) | £8,000 – £35,000 |
| Facial scarring | £3,500 – £40,000 |
| PTSD / anxiety after accident | £4,000 – £55,000 |
The strongest claims start with the cleanest evidence. Gather these as soon as possible:
When signals fail, a junction reverts to give-way under the Highway Code. Both drivers must approach with caution. Council liability is added if the failure was prolonged or known and unrepaired.
✓ Scotland · Scots Law · ✓ No Whiplash Cap · ✓ No Win No Fee
Free, anonymous, and based on Scots-law guideline brackets.
Open the Compensation Calculator